I’ve noticed that quite a few of my fellow bloggers (specifically: Rain, cream kisses, tiannangel) have recently been commenting on this interesting social issue. Therefore, I have decided to join in. That’s what the blogosphere is all about, right?
A very happy Boxing Day to you all; furthermore, happy birthday to Jason W. (today) and Tony (next Tuesday)!
The Popularity Problem
Popularity is a social phenomenon that appears to be experienced in all communities. It is the driving force behind democracy, the catalyst for peer pressure, and the aesthetic quality that many people use to evaluate their own self-worth.
“Would you rather date a girl/guy who was good looking and nice and popular, or a girl/guy who was good looking, nice but a complete and utter social reject? “
The status quo is that people tend to place a lot of value in being popular. Popular people are often seen as superior, “higher up on the social ladder” than those who are not.
Defining popularity
“I think the key to being ‘popular’ is that people envy you for one reason or another.”
From my observations, there are two ways to define popularity:
- Popularity is a measure of how widely appreciated and well-known somebody or something is. If you’re famous and people like you, then you have a form of popularity.
- Popularity is a rank or status that has been granted to you by association. If you’re associated with the people, activities, behaviours, etc. that are well-liked, then you have a form of popularity, because you’re associated with those well-liked things.
If used as an adjective or adverb, “popular” usually refers to the first definition. If you are popular as a person, your popularity is an attribute that has been bestowed upon you because it’s clear that you’re well-liked and well-known.
If used as a noun, “popular” usually refers to the second definition. If you are a popular, then more often than not, you’re accepted as belonging to a group of individuals that has already been labelled as “the popular ones”, often because they are associated with what has already become well-liked and well-known.
Of course, it is possible to have a combination of these attributes:

Becoming (a) popular
“I’ll help you be popular! You’ll hang with the right cohorts, you’ll be good at sports, know the slang you’ve got to know…”
— Popular from the musical Wicked
Becoming a popular seems to be a very natural pathway to becoming popular as a person. It can be seen as standing on the shoulders of giants (as per Isaac Newton), but in a social pursuit, not an academic one.
If I wanted to be a popular, I would hang out with people already established as being popular, and in doing so, share their interests (e.g. DOTA, hip-hop music, anime, PSPs). I would then be able to better relate to them, and empathise rather than simply sympathise with them. Ultimately, I would be accepted, and I would have a sense of belonging. Et voilà, I’d have become associated with the group of individuals already labelled as being the populars.
However, to become truly well-liked and well-known, I would have to be something unique and valuable, while still retaining my status as being a popular. Perhaps my amazing good looks and nice clothes will attract everyone, or perhaps it’ll be my fantastic break-dancing abilities.
In fact, often, there is so much pressure on populars (as in definition #2) to be popular (as in definition #1) that they need a combination of these. It’s almost like having so much competition finding a job that you’re getting qualifications that you technically don’t need, just so that you’ll be that little more outstanding, in the literal sense of the word.
Unpopular populars
“Here’s a question: are all guys attracted to the pretty popular vixens at least once in their high school lives?”
It’s not unusual for populars (as in definition #2) to be even less popular (as in definition #1) than those who are not populars. There are cases where populars are seen as superficial, corrupt, deceptive, manipulating, and selfish.
Admittedly, sometimes it could just be a case of Tall Poppy Syndrome (i.e. jealousy), but I believe there is a much broader and much deeper reason for the curiosity of unpopular populars.
Fame turns into infamy out of a false sense of security. What can happen to populars is that they start to believe that they can do anything, having are already been associated with what is well-liked and well-known. They might start behaving in a way that communicates a sense of arrogant superiority, leading to hatred from the people who are not populars.
Because they have already been labelled as being populars (by definition #2), they will still be populars. However, they will not be popular people (by definition #1), because they have lost almost everything that resembles admiration or respect from others. Nevertheless, they will generally retain their close relationships with each other, and thus will be spared from the cruel situation of being loners or “rejects”.
The percentage of populars who are unpopular varies, depending on what community you’re looking at. Interestingly, in my grade at school, almost all the populars (definition #2) are popular (definition #1).
Popularity without being a popular
“… I came to be the leader of the anti-social group. We clung to each other as a way of validating of all those social people.”
— Bill Gates at Harvard University Graduation Ceremony
Throughout this text, it’s been implicit that typically, you would have to be a popular to be popular as a person. However, this is not necessarily true; consider, for example, Bill Gates, who (as demonstrated in the quotation above) was popular among the non-populars.
Gates demonstrates that popularity (definition #1) doesn’t need to involve any associating with pre-existing populars at all. Popularity can be earned independently through universally-appreciated traits such as leadership, charisma, kindness, and interest in other people.
It’s also important to remember that popularity is dependent on what you define as your community. If you’ve already found your place among people who are not populars, but who like you and know you well, then you are, by all means, a popular person. You’re just not a popular.
So, where do you stand?
“I don’t wish to be everything to everyone, but I would like to be something to someone.”
In many ways, a person’s popularity is like an ATAR. All the small things add up (but in different proportions) to approximate where they “should” stand on the social hierarchy. There is, however, an important difference: ATARs are crunched out by the University Admissions Centre, an authoritative entity, while your popularity is whatever your community thinks it should be.
For both systems, the idea is basically to place everyone on a one-dimension continuum, where the only directions are up and down:

It is my opinion that popularity is just one part of a person’s identity, and a relatively insignificant one at that. There is so much more to you than what other people think of you.
“When you are in a mindset that is preoccupied with pleasing other people – not that this is inherently a bad thing – you will automatically be ruling out a lot of potential avenues, projects, and opportunities for you to be a better person.”
— Chris Nahm
In dealing with other people, we should aim to strengthen our relationships with individuals, not to strengthen our relationship with a social popularity system – whose existence we cannot deny, but whose importance we can defy. ∎














